|
Post by koos on Aug 14, 2020 14:16:24 GMT
I will be missing your reviews of AoS Ayanami. As usual I agree with your analysis. However I simply step over all the flaws and still consider it a great episode. The only real disappointment is that Fitzsimmons retired. Hell, they should be in space to make the scientific discoveries instead of Daisy. *sigh* I’m disappointed that for some reason we will probably never fully understand, one of the show’s original – and most beloved! – characters was only in this final season for one full episode and a couple of minutes. Screentime that was ultimately used to first give us some cryptic hints and then such a rushed and cramped-in-there explanation, that the whole solution in the finale might as well qualify as a deus ex machina. Oh, and the reason why everything from Fitzsimmons’ POV was so overly dramatic and super urgent was because they have a kid now?!? Wow, way to make everything about yourselves, guys! I mean, screw all those billions of people in that other timeline you just created, right?? Well, Iain was unavailable doing something for the BBC at the time and apparently to get him the ep 11 was a big operation on itself. I don't blame the writers for it. However, I do blame ABC for it since they suddenly decided to film it way earlier. And I very much agree with you that it was rushed. It was also needlessly complicated and it made no sense that the person who had seen the timestream didn't go back in time with the team. But I guess that his mind can handle the timestream, but can't handle the barely useful memory block device.
|
|
|
Post by ayanami on Aug 14, 2020 18:49:01 GMT
I will be missing your reviews of AoS Ayanami. As usual I agree with your analysis. However I simply step over all the flaws and still consider it a great episode. The only real disappointment is that Fitzsimmons retired. Hell, they should be in space to make the scientific discoveries instead of Daisy. Yeah, I'd love to be able to do that, too. To be fair, even in many of the show's episodes that I actually really loved, there was usually something stupid that I was able to ignore, though, thanks to the rest of the ep being awesome. However, once we get to the point where I would have to break out some crazy parkour moves just to be able to get over all the flaws, the rest of the ep is hardly ever worth it. Plus, to be completely honest, even if I ignore the stuff in the finale that was downright bad, or rushed or nonsensical, I'm having a really hard time right now to come up with anything I actually really liked. Like I said in my review, Deke interrupting Sousa to offer to stay behind was a good moment. The way he did it was funny, it was a good way to end his character arc and Deke really was the only one from the team who would have fit right into the time period. BUT, there was also so much wrong with that scene! Like, really, what the hell was Sousa even going to do?? It was nice of him to volunteer, but, while he might not exactly be impressed by a lightbulb, he also doesn't really have any technical skills whatsoever. Also, why were the Shield extras totally ignored? I mean, they were fine with handing some potentially powerful items their families had been guarding for decades over to some complete strangers, you'd think they'd be willing to step in once those strangers offered to get rid of the alien invasion for them. And, yeah, the fact that nobody on the team except Mack, not even Nana, gave enough of a sh*t about Deke to actually say goodbye was really just the nail in the coffin for me. Aside from that, only one moment right at the end of the finale really had any emotional value for me, and that was when Skye and Coulson were the only ones left at the holo meeting. Skye and AC saying goodbye, until next time, right before Coulson flies off with Lola. Well, yeah, that was a good final touch to the episode right there. Most of the rest of it, though, I'm pretty sure I will have forgotten by next week. Well, if that really was the case that the BBC project completely filled up Iain's schedule, then I don't understand why an actor that plays one the show’s original – and most beloved! – characters doesn't have a contract that prohibits him from taking on any projects that interfere with his main employment. As far as I know, that would be standard. Also, even if the writers are exempt from any blame regarding Fitz's available screentime, that doesn't excuse their terrible handling of what we did get to see of him. Like you said, it was needlessly complicated. I was really looking forward to having Fitz back on the show, but if I had known that most of his time would be spend on rushing everyone through a season's worth of exposition, maybe I could have actually managed to go without it.
|
|
|
Post by ayanami on Aug 15, 2020 0:06:22 GMT
Overall it was a good finale! The last few minutes were pure joy. A little sad on one hand but happy they all ended up alive and still doing their thing! I will write more tomorrow and can't wait to hear what others thought but overall I'll give an 8/10. Some things bugged me, others confused the hell out of me lol but really enjoyed most of it! I suppose I might be the only one here who feels this way, but I found the entire ending scene in the bar to be almost unbearably lame. Mostly, I think, because the mood and the actual circumstances just did not go together at all. There was a sadness in that scene - almost a wistfulness - that had worked very well on the show in at least two previous occasions: The first time, when the team was forced to say their silent goodbyes from afar to Bobbi and Hunter in S3, as the two had no choice but to leave to protect the agency. The second time was the finale of S5, right in the wake of the original Fitz's death and with the team fully aware that Coulson would die as well soon, and they were saying goodbye to him for good. Those two moments on the show were heartbreaking and they absolutely called for a sombre tone that the writers, directors, camera people and actors managed to convey just beautifully! This time, however, we have a bunch of people on an advanced zoom call, because they recently decided to take different career paths and are too caught up in their own lives to actually try and set a dinner date at some point. That is just in no way comparable and I found it pretty much laughable that someone had actually decided to go with "wistful longing" as the theme of the occasion. I mean, of course they could have also been mourning the people they recently lost, but since that were only Enoch and Deke, and it has been made abundantly clear that no-one on the team actually cared about them, that obviously wasn't it, either.
|
|
|
Post by Hari Seldon on Aug 15, 2020 4:42:16 GMT
Took me a while to get through the posts here before writing anything. Having the power go out for a while didn't help. I was entertained, but still had a couple of things that bothered me that haven't been mentioned so far.
First off, one of my predictions (that I'm not sure I mentioned here) that I wanted to be wrong about did come to pass: With the creation of the alternate time stream and the team finding a way to get back to their own stream, nothing that they did apart from picking up Sousa and losing Deke (ok, I didn't predict losing Deke) mattered. Yes, Fitz gave a throwaway line about them having to go through the process, but as far as the population outside of the team is concerned, this season never happened. They could have let the Chronicoms take over the other timeline without chasing them, and nobody would have known the difference. Secondly, while people talk about characters being overpowered, Fitz was overbrained. With all of the stuff he did in these episodes, especially doing the navigation of the quantum realm, they've got him smarter than Tony Stark and Hank Pym put together. No BS about building off their work - this appears not to be the line where the Avengers beat Thanos, so Tony wouldn't have invented the quantum GPS and it's a guarantee that Hank Pym didn't put his quantum realm work up on the SHIELD database.
I'm not going to go back and find the quote, but there was a complaint about Kora broadcasting the emotions - not accurate, they used the Chronicom device Sybil used to communicate with the hunters and Kora simply boosted the power on it. I'm not saying that her boosting the power made a lot of sense, just that it's what she did. As far as that device goes, did it remind anyone else of the "point of view" gun from the 2005 Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy movie (probably the only good thing in that movie)?
Edit: Forgot to put in the chat capture...
|
|
|
Post by ayanami on Aug 15, 2020 5:27:32 GMT
Took me a while to get through the posts here before writing anything. Having the power go out for a while didn't help. I was entertained, but still had a couple of things that bothered me that haven't been mentioned so far.
First off, one of my predictions (that I'm not sure I mentioned here) that I wanted to be wrong about did come to pass: With the creation of the alternate time stream and the team finding a way to get back to their own stream, nothing that they did apart from picking up Sousa and losing Deke (ok, I didn't predict losing Deke) mattered. Yes, Fitz gave a throwaway line about them having to go through the process, but as far as the population outside of the team is concerned, this season never happened. They could have let the Chronicoms take over the other timeline without chasing them, and nobody would have known the difference. Secondly, while people talk about characters being overpowered, Fitz was overbrained. With all of the stuff he did in these episodes, especially doing the navigation of the quantum realm, they've got him smarter than Tony Stark and Hank Pym put together. No BS about building off their work - this appears not to be the line where the Avengers beat Thanos, so Tony wouldn't have invented the quantum GPS and it's a guarantee that Hank Pym didn't put his quantum realm work up on the SHIELD database. I'm not going to go back and find the quote, but there was a complaint about Kora broadcasting the emotions - not accurate, they used the Chronicom device Sybil used to communicate with the hunters and Kora simply boosted the power on it. I'm not saying that her boosting the power made a lot of sense, just that it's what she did. As far as that device goes, did it remind anyone else of the "point of view" gun from the 2005 Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy movie (probably the only good thing in that movie)? Edit: Forgot to put in the chat capture... Lol, yeah, I know you're right. Even when I wrote that, I was like, "Well, okay, I think that wasn't technically what-- Oh, whatever! If the show didn't even bother to properly make sense of Kora's powers, why the hell should I?" So, yeah, I was pissed off and lazy. You got me.
|
|
|
Post by Hari Seldon on Aug 15, 2020 14:04:35 GMT
Even when I wrote that, I was like, "Well, okay, I think that wasn't technically what-- Oh, whatever! If the show didn't even bother to properly make sense of Kora's powers, why the hell should I?" So, yeah, I was pissed off and lazy. You got me. Not to worry, we don't love you any less for it.
The firewall part bugged me more than anything else, but that's probably the result of having worked in the IT field (obviously the show didn't have any consultants who ever had). I know, accurate computer usage would be really boring on screen.
|
|
|
Post by Black Widow on Aug 15, 2020 14:46:18 GMT
Hm I just had a thought. With John Garrett dead in the alternate reality much sooner in the Prime AoS reality, does this mean that Victoria Hand recruits Grant Ward or does Grant stay in prison?
|
|
|
Post by Hari Seldon on Aug 15, 2020 16:02:59 GMT
Hm I just had a thought. With John Garrett dead in the alternate reality much sooner in the Prime AoS reality, does this mean that Victoria Hand recruits Grant Ward or does Grant stay in prison? Here's my thought: they should have done another time jump and during the time they jumped over, Nate should have recruited Ward, Ward should have been given some powers, Ward should have killed Nate, then Ward should have been the final villain. Brett probably would have jumped at the chance. Actually, give Ward the electricity power of Lincoln just to get Daisy extra angry.
On a side note, I'm about halfway through Lil's live viewing, having just gotten to the second episode. ayanami was quite vocal about Daisy being dismissive of Deke and on the live view Chloe has just joined in and Jeff Ward is there with her at her house. I know that has nothing to do with the actual episode, but I still like the irony of it.
|
|
|
Post by haxemon on Aug 17, 2020 20:39:13 GMT
|
|
|
Post by ayanami on Aug 17, 2020 23:41:15 GMT
Okay, so I skipped through that a bit, because these types of videos are mostly just BS imo. They either spend an hour talking about the most obvious clues, or they start reaching for the most far-fetched explanations for things that are usually just oversights by the real life people working on a project. That said, I would totally be on board with an Agents of S.W.O.R.D. series! Bring Skye and Sousa into the fold, have Hunter come on board (he did run the agency in the comics at some point, right? ), hop timelines, whatever. Awesome! However, somehow I think that the Triskelion still standing in the finale scene of AoS was more of a goof than anything else. At this point, I seriously would not put it past the people working on AoS to have been like: "Look, here we show the Triskelion still standing so as to prove that this is not the timeline where the Chronicoms basically destroyed all of Shield!" Meanwhile, they had entirely forgotten that the Triskelion having been destroyed during the Hydra uprising in The Winter Soldier is undeniably AoS canon. I mean, seriously, how else does this make sense? I get the concept of reality hopping, but it was stressed that they would return to their original timeline in the finale. That's where Fitz came from and that's where Piper and Flint were waiting for him and the others to return. And in that timeline it has been confirmed that the events of The Winter Soldier took place, including the destruction of the Triskelion. So unless the team somehow ended up in a different timeline, where a different Piper and Flint were waiting for them in the exact same location at the exact same moment, I call BS and say that the writers or whoever made that visual simply didn't think this part through. Just like AoS has a looong history of not thinking things through.
|
|
|
Post by DoTheMath on Aug 18, 2020 2:00:34 GMT
|
|
|
Post by Hari Seldon on Aug 18, 2020 4:18:03 GMT
One bit I said over on a youtube comment, but somehow forgot to mention here. "Alya", the name of FitzSimmons' daughter is spelled differently, but sounds just the same as "Alia". Alia (St. Alia of the Knife) was the sister of Paul Atredes in the Dune series. Kyle MacLachlan, who played Daisy's father on AoS, played Paul Atredes in the Dune movie. By a stretch of logic and wishful thinking, this means that FitzSimmons named their child after Daisy's aunt.
|
|
|
Post by Black Widow on Aug 18, 2020 10:09:03 GMT
Unfortunate. I love references to the movies.
|
|
|
Post by haxemon on Aug 18, 2020 12:15:28 GMT
Okay, so I skipped through that a bit, because these types of videos are mostly just BS imo. They either spend an hour talking about the most obvious clues, or they start reaching for the most far-fetched explanations for things that are usually just oversights by the real life people working on a project. ... Yeah I agree 100% though I've found that New Rockstars are generally better most of the time. Though even they sometimes mix in rumors and leaks etc. from future projects which I wish they wouldn't. I think I agree with you about the Triskellion. Or at least I'm not sure it "proves" a non-Earth-199999 timeline. I had felt a long time ago that the AoS timeline was different - going back to the destroyer of worlds season. But even then, the Triskellion would have been lost. I mean, Winter Soldier is about as close to AoS canon as any MCU film since it's the one most closely tied in. As for rebuilding it just like it was, I get that it's not guaranteed but who's to say that's not what happened? But yeah, it does feel like it may have either been a pure goof or if it was "written in" on purpose it may mean something else. I doubt it would be intended as "whoops - maybe something still got changed" since Coulson and others would have noticed of course. Anyway, I hope if nothing else we'll see Agents of SWORD a little more tied in. And if they don't literally use Daisy and Sousa on the show I hope they at least find a way to tie AoS to AoS (the other S).
|
|
|
Post by DoTheMath on Aug 20, 2020 1:19:48 GMT
|
|